Make That Four Theories
(#4. Overreaction)
In my post on Thursday, "National Moratorium on Foreclosures," I puzzled over the seeming disconnect between the stocks of publicly-traded title insurance companies (barely affected), and the supposed tidal wave of claims headed their way due to defective mortgage foreclosures.
I posited three possible explanations: 1) the aforementioned companies don't have exposure in the markets where the problems are most severe; 2) they've already laid off their risk, through reinsurance, derivatives, or the like; and/or 3) the banks, not the title insurance companies, are going to take the hit.
Based on this week's stock market action, the clear winner is theory #3 (all the too-big-to-fail banks -- including Bank of America, Wells Fargo, and JP Morgan Chase -- had rough weeks).
SARS vs. AIDS
But I'd now also add a fourth theory: the problem, while serious, has been exaggerated.
Think of it as the financial equivalent of a possible health epidemic.
In 2003, much of the developed world was bracing for a full-blown outbreak of SARS ("severe acute respiratory syndrome").
The quick spike in (well-documented) cases -- fanned by all manner of media -- was certainly alarming.
And SARS in fact was extremely lethal if contracted.
But ultimately, nothing like the pandemic officials initially feared occurred.
Other scares like West Nile virus have followed the same trajectory.
It's too soon to tell -- all 50 state attorneys general are now looking into the matter -- but it's possible that the stories about homeowners with no mortgages having their locks changed in the middle of the night are the (rare) exception, not the rule.
At least in Minnesota, the fact that I haven't heard first-person accounts from a pretty broad circle of clients and friends tells me that that's at least plausible.
Showing posts with label Bank of America. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bank of America. Show all posts
Saturday, October 16, 2010
Saturday, January 9, 2010
Bank of America: Slashed Dividends, Billions in Pay
Dear Bank of America:
Who Do You Think You %!#% Work For??
First, a personal disclosure: my wife and I own a couple hundred shares of Bank of America. We've owned them for more than a decade, and they are now worth less than what we paid.
Adjusted for inflation, we've actually lost more than one-third of our original investment.
Call that risk without return.
After reaching a high of almost $50 a share more than two years ago, the stock briefly crumbled to less than $4, and has now partially recovered to just under $17.
A year ago, the dividend was slashed 98%, where it remains today.
So, is Bank of America's leadership now embarrassed and humble? Maybe even a little contrite?
Fat chance:
Is this Wall Street's new social contract with America's savers and investors?
FDR would be (and likely is) rolling over in his grave.
P.S.: to answer the question, "Who do you think you work for?" Clearly, themselves.
Who Do You Think You %!#% Work For??
First, a personal disclosure: my wife and I own a couple hundred shares of Bank of America. We've owned them for more than a decade, and they are now worth less than what we paid.
Adjusted for inflation, we've actually lost more than one-third of our original investment.
Call that risk without return.
After reaching a high of almost $50 a share more than two years ago, the stock briefly crumbled to less than $4, and has now partially recovered to just under $17.
A year ago, the dividend was slashed 98%, where it remains today.
So, is Bank of America's leadership now embarrassed and humble? Maybe even a little contrite?
Fat chance:
At Bank of America, traders and bankers are wondering how much Brian T. Moynihan, the bank’s new chief, will be awarded for 2010. Bank of America, which is still absorbing Merrill Lynch, is expected to pay large bonuses, given the bank’s sizable trading profits. “We’re paying for results, and there were some areas of the company that had terrific results, and they will be compensated for that,” said a Bank of America spokesman.
--"For Top Bonuses on Wall Street, 7 Figures or 8?"; The New York Times (1/9/2010)
Is this Wall Street's new social contract with America's savers and investors?
FDR would be (and likely is) rolling over in his grave.
P.S.: to answer the question, "Who do you think you work for?" Clearly, themselves.
Wednesday, January 7, 2009
Bailout Math
Bailout Money Bolsters Banks
Against Prospective Losses?
"A good hockey player plays where the puck is. A great hockey player plays where the puck is going to be. "
--Wayne Gretsky
It's a stretch to compare Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke and Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson to the incomparable Wayne Gretsky; their ad hoc and inconsistent handling of the credit crisis more often conjures up images of the Keystone Cops.
It's also the case that the lack of disclosure and accountability expected of the recipient banks is truly appallling, and to many (including me) offensive, given the hundreds of billions of taxpayer funds involved.
That said, if you're looking for a rationale for and defense of the bailout(s), however strained, here it is:
--Wells Fargo just bought Wachovia and its $150 billion portfolio of toxic mortgage loans (mostly option-ARM's and the like).
--Two-thirds of those loans, or $100 billion, are now expected to default.
--The loss ratio on the aforesaid defaults is expected to be 25%, or $25 billion.
So guess how much Wells Fargo has received in bailout funds to date? Yup: about $25 billion.
Thanks to Tyler Zimmerman, Edina Mortgage, and Josh Kaplan, City Lakes office manager, for the foregoing numbers and proofreading, respectively.
Against Prospective Losses?
"A good hockey player plays where the puck is. A great hockey player plays where the puck is going to be. "
--Wayne Gretsky
It's a stretch to compare Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke and Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson to the incomparable Wayne Gretsky; their ad hoc and inconsistent handling of the credit crisis more often conjures up images of the Keystone Cops.
It's also the case that the lack of disclosure and accountability expected of the recipient banks is truly appallling, and to many (including me) offensive, given the hundreds of billions of taxpayer funds involved.
That said, if you're looking for a rationale for and defense of the bailout(s), however strained, here it is:
--Wells Fargo just bought Wachovia and its $150 billion portfolio of toxic mortgage loans (mostly option-ARM's and the like).
--Two-thirds of those loans, or $100 billion, are now expected to default.
--The loss ratio on the aforesaid defaults is expected to be 25%, or $25 billion.
So guess how much Wells Fargo has received in bailout funds to date? Yup: about $25 billion.
Thanks to Tyler Zimmerman, Edina Mortgage, and Josh Kaplan, City Lakes office manager, for the foregoing numbers and proofreading, respectively.
Labels:
Bailout,
Bank of America,
Bernanke,
option-ARM's,
Paulson,
Wachovia
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
