My blog has moved! Redirecting...

You should be automatically redirected. If not, visit http://rosskaplan.com and update your bookmarks.

Showing posts with label Miranda Warning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Miranda Warning. Show all posts

Friday, October 22, 2010

No Free Houses

Mortgage Foreclosure Mess

Two weeks or so into the mortgage foreclosure mess, some of the dust is settling regarding what could potentially be hundreds of thousands of homes improperly foreclosed upon by the big banks.

First, what's not going to happen: people who lost their homes in such fashion are not going to get them back, with their mortgage somehow erased.

My guess is that people are watching too much CSI, or Perry Mason re-runs, or whatever TV program shows "perps" walking because of a technicality (due to police improperly seizing evidence, not informing defendants of their Miranda rights, etc.).

News flash: if you were months (or years) delinquent on your mortgage and were foreclosed on as a result . . . the courts ain't giving you your house back.

Issue #2: Banks' Put-Back Exposure

Meanwhile, the issue that very much appears in play is whether the big banks will have to effectively buy back billions in mortgages they sold to investors.

The same sloppy documentation that led to defective foreclosures apparently may also be legal grounds for investors to escape billions in losses on now very soured mortgages.

If investors can show that the banks misrepresented the types and characteristics of the mortgages they securitized (bundled) and sold, they may essentially be able to return them for a full refund.

Bracing for that possibility (and the huge losses that would result), the stock market has punished the share prices of several big banks.

Tuesday, July 13, 2010

Real Estate's "Miranda Warning"

Why Buyers Shouldn't Talk Directly to Listing Agents

The person in custody must, prior to interrogation, be clearly informed that he or she has the right to remain silent, and that anything the person says will be used against that person in court.

--U.S. Supreme Court; Miranda v. Arizona decision (1966)

As a listing agent, I strongly discourage my selling clients from talking to the Buyer's agent, beyond exchanging social niceties.

In fact, direct contact between a represented client and the other side's agent is inappropriate; all communication is supposed to be between the two agents.

In practice, however, the Buyer's agent and Seller can cross paths when the former is previewing (looking at a home without their client), and the Seller is home.

"Hot Summer we're having" is certainly harmless enough.

"How many showings have you had, and what have people been saying?" isn't.

Seller Blunders

Perhaps the most damning -- and costly -- blunder I've heard of involved a Seller who let slip that their Contingency had been called, and that they'd lose their dream home unless they found a Buyer for theirs in the next 48 hours.

According to the agent who related the story, the Buyer's offer just dropped $20k.

Even if Sellers don't say anything compromising, sometimes, just their "body English" (facial expressions, general demeanor, etc.) betrays them. That's especially so if they're discouraged or impatient about how things are going.

Call it the real estate "Miranda Warning": anything you say (or telegraph) can and will be used against you.

Buyer Blunders

The same holds true for Buyers talking directly to Listing agents.

Case in point:

I recently met a Buyer, their agent, and the Buyer's contractor at a home I was listing to discuss repairs they were requesting of the Seller, including a wiring issue in the Kitchen.

Since the wiring was inaccessible and the Buyer insisted that the home required extensive remodeling (hence their low offer), I suggested it would be much cheaper to fix the wiring once the Kitchen walls were opened up.

At that point, the Buyer interjected, "Oh, no -- we love the Kitchen just the way it is!"

Oops.

Goodbye, negotiating leverage.

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Financial "Miranda Warning" for Goldman Sachs Clients?

Oops, They Did it Again!

If we're not going to shut down rogue investment banks like Goldman Sachs, or break them up into smaller, less economy-threatening pieces, how about at least requiring that they give their clients (hard to believe they still have any) the equivalent of a financial "Miranda warning."

Something like this perhaps:

You have the right not to borrow or otherwise do business with us. However, if you do, everything we learn about your financial condition can and will be used against you, by us or our affiliates, to maximize our profit. Oh . . . and the financial products we sell you . . . may be dangerous to your financial health (and everyone else's!)

In the unfolding saga of Greece's sovereign debt mess, consider -- once again -- who seems to be at the dirty little epicenter (and apparently, cashing in again):

Goldman Sachs and J.P. Morgan, and perhaps others, sold financial instruments to Greece that were designed to artificially depress its borrowing and budget deficits.
Goldman and Morgan declined to comment. Greece says what it did was legal at the time.

Now Greece is under attack in the markets, and the major countries in the euro zone are trying to force it to clean up its act and to keep it from defaulting. There is little agreement on how to do that. Traders who bet against Greece — by shorting Greek bonds while buying German ones, for example — have made a lot of money as the market realized just how much trouble Greece was in.

The European Union is now asking Greece for details of what it did. But it should go further. It should seek to find out if the banks that helped Greece lie — and thus knew its numbers were false — made money betting against it. If so, do those banks deserve to keep those profits?

--Floyd Norris, "Helping Governments Deceive"; The New York Times (2/16/2010)

One more time, louder and all together:

A-r-r-g-h-h!