My blog has moved! Redirecting...

You should be automatically redirected. If not, visit http://rosskaplan.com and update your bookmarks.

Showing posts with label Twin Cities housing market. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Twin Cities housing market. Show all posts

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Is Peter Schiff Right About Housing?

Schiff: ‘Home Prices Are Still Too High’

The market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.

–John Maynard Keynes

Just for argument’s sake, assume that Peter Schiff’s Op-Ed piece in today’s Wall Street Journal is right: namely, that even after a 30%-plus drop nationally the last four years, U.S. housing is still overvalued by at least 20% (never mind various benchmarks indicating that housing has never been more affordable).

Should you heed Schiff’s advice, and wait till housing prices regress towards their historical mean?

Or even longer, until they overshoot on the down side? (as Schiff speculates will happen).

The problem with relying on historical trend lines to make long-term decisions like buying a family home is that you may be waiting a long time.

On the Sidelines

In fact, according to Schiff’s preferred benchmark — “Standard & Poor’s Case-Schiller 10-City Home Price Index” — the last time home prices nationally were at or below their historical averages was . . . 1998.

Ala Keynes, that’s a long time to wait -- presumably in an apartment or rental home -- for a mean reversion.

If you got married and started a family then, your oldest child would now be nearing junior high school while you waited, patiently, for housing prices to correct all the back to the long-term mean.

Understandably, most people don’t suspend their lives based on such historical considerations.

They buy homes when their life circumstances dictate — and they can afford to.

When people have better housing choices buying rather than renting — which certainly seems to be the case today, in the Twin Cities and many other cities nationally — that’s usually what they do.

Wednesday, December 29, 2010

Seller Liability for Ice Dams

Who Pays?

Unfortunately, the way this Winter is unfolding, the first major (and expensive) repair facing many people who bought Twin Cities homes this Fall is for ice dams.

Can they look to their Sellers to absorb some -- or all -- of the expense?

Legal Standard

To answer the question, first revisit the two-pronged legal standard for recovery: 1) the problem existed before the Buyer purchased the home; and 2) the Seller knew -- or should have known -- about the problem.

So, if you closed on one of those balmy October days we enjoyed this Fall . . . you likely flunk #1, never mind about #2.

Pre-existing Condition

But what if the home historically suffered from ice dams, and this year's are simply the latest recurrence?

Usually, there's residual evidence that a home previously had ice dams, even after the damagehas been repaired.

Plus, a good home inspector will note the roof's pitch and design, following any roof valleys to the home's interior ceiling(s) to look for signs of past leaking (stains, fresh paint, etc.).

Seller Disclosure

Of course, at least in Minnesota, the Home Seller is obliged to tell prospective Buyers if they've previously had ice dams -- or any other roof damage -- in state-mandated disclosure forms.

Misrepresenting such material information not only risks liability for fraud (and its open-ended statute of limitations), but isn't likely to fool a Buyer who does their due diligence.

For all those reasons, it's likely that either a home hasn't previously had ice dams -- or, if it did, the issue was identified and dealt with prior to closing.

Bottom line?

Just like Buyers usually can't recover from Sellers when, post-closing, they get water in their basement after a rare, torrential rain, it's unlikely that they have recourse for ice dams following this year's record-breaking December snowfall.

Fortunately, most homeowners' insurance policies cover ice dam-related roof damage, subject to a deductible.

"The Edgewater" in Uptown

Minneapolis' Most Discounted Condo?

I've blogged previously about deeply discounted single family homes in the Twin Cities.

A second-floor condo (#201) in The Edgewater (pictured above) may very well be the Twin Cities' most discounted condo.

Now at $749,823, the unit was originally listed for $1.981 million almost exactly three years ago.

That's a whopping 62% reduction!

"But Can You Afford the Property Taxes?"

The catch?

Not the A+ location, just off the Northeast corner of Minneapolis' Lake Calhoun.

And not the 2005 building it's in, a gleaming glass-and-stone structure with sleek walls of windows, great views, and open floor plans.

Rather, my guess is that it's the $19,000 annual property tax bill that is still attached to the unit, courtesy of its $1.35 million tax assessed value.

Opportunity Knocks

Does such a mismatch spell opportunity?

In this case, I think it does.

That's because the property isn't a short sale or foreclosure, where the tax authorities can (and do) argue that the ultimate purchase price doesn't reflect fair market value since it was a "distressed sale" -- and therefore disregard the sales price.

Translation: if you pay say, $725,000, that's also presumptively the new tax assessed value -- and that $19k property tax bill plummets.

In fact, if the Buyer closes in the next few months, they still have time to contest Hennepin County's 2012 assessment (determined January 2, 2011).

Wednesday, December 8, 2010

Year-End Pick-Up in Activity

The Limits of Statistics
in Valuing Homes

It's only Wednesday, and I've already fielded three calls this week from appraisers wanting "scoop" on recent, closed sales that I've handled.

A year-end pick-up in deals?

Well, that, too.

However, in each case the appraiser was working on a refinancing application.

To approve the new loan, the lender needed to establish current market value, which in turn means performing an appraisal and identifying/analyzing the Comp's -- just like they would for a sale.

The fact that appraisers need to talk to actual, live Realtors -- who can fill them in on floor plans, updates (or not), and other home features not otherwise captured in statistics -- should give anyone relying on Trulia, Zillow, etc. for home values pause.

P.S.: Time permitting, I'm happy to talk to appraisers. Often times, something I know can be the difference between a deal (or refinancing) happening -- or not.

In an environment where banks are looking for any excuse to shoot down a deal, as a plugged-in, on-the-ground expert, I'm ideally positioned to serve as a counter-balance.

Of course, a healthier, more active market benefits everyone.

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

So, Which is It? Down 2.2%? Or Down 26%?

Confusing Housing Statistics

"U.S. Home Sales Fell 26% in October."

--The New York Times (11/23/2010)

"Home Sales Fell 2.2% in October."

--The Wall Street Journal (11/23/2010)

So which is it?

Both, actually.

Home sales fell 26% in October, 2010 compared with October, 2009.

And they dropped 2.2% compared with the preceding month (September, 2010).

However, the real statistic of note for the Twin Cities market is the year-over-year number: down 41%.

That's not much of a surprise to local Realtors.

The only thing dulling the sting a bit is that the October, 2009 numbers were juiced by the (then-looming) tax credit expiration, one month away (November 30, 2009).

Monday, November 22, 2010

"The Unrealistic Buyer": Top 10 Signs

Unrealistic Sellers Meet Their Match

Their counterpart, the Unrealistic Seller, has received more ink and attention, but these days Unrealistic Buyers are just as numerous -- and intractable.

As a public service to would-be Home Sellers, herewith are my top ten signs that you may be dealing with an Unrealistic Buyer (any resemblance to real persons isn't purely coincidental) :

10. They're on their third Realtor -- or don't have one.

9. They've been looking for more than a year . . .

8. and have seen more than 30 homes, which they've all pronounced "grossly overpriced" (and otherwise deficient).

7. They've yet to make an offer on a home.

6. They've already made offers on more than four homes -- none of which has even elicited a (genuine) counter-offer.

5. If they actually receive a serious counter-offer, they refuse to work with it.

4. They know the minutiae of the Purchase Agreement and Addenda as well as their Realtor -- and are better at opening lockboxes.

3. They offer more than 15% below a well-priced home's asking price (see also, #6).

2. They have no discernible timetable or catalyst (new job, baby, expiring lease, etc.) for buying a home (see also, #9).

1. They let you know that they're thinking about getting their real estate license.

There!

Forewarned is forearmed (now read "Serious Buyers: Top 10 Signs" to contrast with the foregoing).

P.S.: Sign #11: they'll only agree to buy something for 20% or more below market . . . if they can sell their current home for 20% above market.

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

A Realtor's Take on Recessions & Booms

"So, How's the Market?"

"A recession is when your neighbor loses their job. A Depression is when you lose yours."

--uttered by Presidents Truman and Reagan (and many others)

Little remarked -- but equally true -- is the converse: a "bounce," at least in the real estate business, is when you are busy; a "boom" is when you're swamped.

That's regardless of what's otherwise happening in your office, the overall market, various parts of town, etc.

After a torrid May-Sept, and a quiet(er) October, I am personally very busy heading into Thanksgiving and the year-end.

The principal caveat: Buyers now are expecting -- and getting -- deals.

P.S.: A colleague characterized this market as one in which "Buyers are getting the last word."

I'd go even further: Buyers in today's market are getting the last sentence -- or paragraph.

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Rising -- and Falling -- Real Estate Bar

Want to Stand Out? Drop > 10%

Want some anecdotal evidence about housing market conditions these days in the Twin Cities?

Higher Bar. Edina Realty, the Twin Cities' largest broker, requires price reductions of 10% or more to qualify for intra-company email distribution (I believe the policy actually dates back to this Summer).

Previously, the requirement was 5%.

The logic?

Five percent drops are now run of the mill; to get Buyers' attention (and qualify for email distribution), the number's got to really be eye-catching (no such threshold exists for circulating price drops within a branch office).

Lower Bar. Meanwhile, the bar for hosting Exceptional Properties meetings in the Southwest Region (the geographic area including my office, City Lakes) continues to drop.

Three years ago, the floor was at least $1 million -- and most homes hosting the meeting were well above that.

Tomorrow's meeting is at a home listed for $589k.

P.S.: many Realtors, including yours truly, have custom email distribution lists to market their listings. The trick is knowing the difference between judicious use of such lists -- and spam.

Thursday, September 2, 2010

Up 63%!

MLS Rentals

No, that's not what some housing market, somewhere, did last month or year, or the first day "pop" in a new IPO ("initial public offering") on Wall Street.

That's the one-day increase in rentals listed on MLS.

Before anyone gets too excited, though, that number reflects an increase from 11 listings to 18.

I'll note when that number hits 1,000; my guess is, before the end of Sept.

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

"Cheaper Than a Car"*

Metro Homes Under $40k

According to a quick search on MLS this morning, there are exactly 463 residential properties in Minneapolis and the West 'burbs for sale for under $40k.

To be sure, the majority are in rough condition, in tougher neighborhoods; the ones that aren't, are typically condo's.

Small condo's.

But still.

When even a crummy studio apartment fetches something like $500 in the Twin Cities, a monthly house payment of $200-$300 (PITI on a $40k property, assuming $1k down and 4.5% interest) sure seems compelling!

*Thanks to City Lakes' Budd Batterson for that line (he has an upcoming Robbinsdale condo that is -- cheaper than a car, that is). And yes, at $40k it would be a very nice car.

Monday, August 30, 2010

Get Ready for Thursday Tour (Thursday??)

You Read it Here First

In the course of helping clients find a rental property the last 2 weeks, it's become abundantly clear that the rental market is much more fragmented and chaotic than the For Sale market.

And pricing is much sloppier (what you get for, say, $2,500/mth runs the gamut from properties worth high $300k's to low $600k's).

While Craig's List seems to dominate, there are another 6-8 sites that have rental properties that aren't listed elsewhere.

And coming this week, rental properties will now be on MLS.

Step 2

Once you've defined the appropriate universe of rental candidates for your client, step #2 is to go look at them.

Some owners and rental brokers are quite responsive, and showings are easy to set up.

However, others take repeated efforts to reach, and have very little time available for showings ("How about after work next Monday?").

For Realtors generally accustomed to getting access during business hours, with a few hours notice, that doesn't cut it.

Proposal: Rental Tour

Once upon at time, For Sale properties suffered from a similar lack of exposure.

At least in the Twin Cities, the solution was to hold open houses every Tuesday, between 11 a.m. and 1 p.m., when Realtors can see all the new inventory.

Here's betting $100 that there'll be something similar for rental properties within the next year (at least ones whose rent justifies the marketing effort).

P.S.: my proposed time is 1 to 3 p.m Thursdays.

Friday, June 4, 2010

Does Networking Really Work?

Instant Access to 1,600 Realtors

Does Realtor-to-Realtor networking really work?

Well, consider this:

With about 20% of the total listings in the Twin Cities housing market, the percentage of Edina Realty listings sold by other Edina Realty agents is 40%.

That could just be because "we" -- all 1,600-plus local Edina Realty agents -- really like one another.

But the truth is, most of us don't even know each other.

What really explains that 40% statistic is the amount of intra-company networking that constantly takes place -- at weekly office meetings, online, via email, etc.

It's always nice to be able to tell a prospective client during a listing presentation (basically, a job interview for Realtors) that, just by pressing "send" on my PC, I can instantly tell 1,600 other Realtors about my hot new listing.

Dual Agency - Two Kinds

When a Buyer represented by an Edina agent sells a home listed by another Edina agent, the resulting relationship is called "dual agency."

That's because both the Buyer and Seller are represented by the same broker, Edina.

While that creates some legal awkwardness, the benefit to clients -- in my opinion -- more than offsets the drawbacks

By contrast, when the same agent represents both the Buyer and Seller, that's called "single agent dual agency."

As they say, "that's a horse of a different color."

While single agent dual agency is permissible with sufficient disclosure and both parties' assent, I personally think it's not worth the risk.

In my opinion, the only way to be on both sides of a deal is ultimately . . . to be on neither.

Monday, May 31, 2010

Missed the Tax Credit? Lucky You

Did the Late Bird Get the Worm??

Although I take issue with some of the math underlying the analysis, there's no denying that the drop in interest rates since April 30 -- thanks to the Eurozone crisis -- has at least partially offset the benefit(s) associated with now-expired home buyer tax credits.

Missing the tax credit deadline might have seemed like a big mistake to some home buyers, but waiting could have been the smartest thing to do. Interest rates have fallen so dramatically since April 30th that the typical purchaser of a $350,000 home, financed with a $280,000 mortgage, would have saved a bundle by waiting until May.

At April’s average rate of 5.34 percent, a home buyer would have locked in a 30-year fixed rate loan with a monthly payment of $1,561.82. The same borrower could have snagged a 30-year fixed rate loan at a rate of 4.625 percent in May and paid $1,439.59 per month. That’s a $1,467 annual savings. Over 30 years, it’s a $44,003 savings, dwarfing the tax credit.

--"Post-Tax Credit Buyers May Save Money"; Daily Real Estate News (5/27/2010)

So what's wrong/incomplete about the above analysis (at least if you live in the Twin Cities)?

Three things.

One. The average home sale in the Twin Cities currently is about half the $350,000 cited in the foregoing excerpt (no doubt written by a journalist in New York or LA).

So, cut the monthly mortgage savings from $95 to $47.50 -- making the tax credit that much more valuable.

Two. The average home buyer doesn't stay in their home for 30 years.

In fact, seven years is more typical.

Three. The calculations don't discount for the time value of money (why people prefer "a bird in the hand to two in the bush").

In plain English, most first-time home Buyers would rather have an immediate $8,000 (or $6,500, for move-up Buyers) than an extra $95 every month for 30 years.

However, the whole episode does serve to underscore that the decision to buy a home depends on many variables, including interest rates, prevailing home prices, financial incentives, etc.

Vicissitudes of Timing

The post-tax credit drop in interest rates also shows how (fickle) market conditions can trump . . . everything else.

Case in point: I worked with a client last year whose plan was to buy a newer, bigger home, then sell their existing home. That strategy made sense because their current home needed quite a bit of updating -- work that, realistically, could only happen once it was vacant.

Part one went off without a hitch: my client got a great deal on a very nice Plymouth home, and proceeded to move in.

However, part two suffered delay after delay.

So, instead of having their home ready for sale in February, at the beginning of the "Spring" selling season, my client's home wasn't on the market until May.

Did the delay hurt them?

On the contrary, several homes that were competing with my client's home all got snatched up in the interim.

As a result, my clients were able to raise their asking price -- and got it, in the first two weeks!

Sunday, May 30, 2010

"Location, Location, Condition"

"Not a Drive-By"

Quick, test your knowledge of Twin Cities real estate, and guess how much the single family home pictured above is listed for:

A. $149,000
B. $249,000
C. $419,900
D. $599,900

Give up?

Here are three more, very significant clues: 1) the home has been completely remodeled; 2) it's located in Minneapolis' tony Kenwood neighborhood (just east of Lake of the Isles, and close to downtown; 3) appearances to the contrary, it's over 3,000 FSF.

Correct answer: D

As they say, "the curb appeal is deceptive" (also commonly billed as "not a drive-by").

P.S.: and yes, curb appeal matters: the home has been on the market for over one year.

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

Twin Cities Housing Market: Quirks & Curiousities

The More, The Merrier?

One of the weird things about the local housing market at the moment is that small, entry-level homes are hard to find -- and (therefore) seem to be fetching a healthy premium.

Meanwhile, north of seven figures, there seem to be TONS of choices, many steeply discounted.

That disconnect suggests a solution (I'm kidding, but not completely):

Groups of first-time Buyers should combine to buy large, upper bracket homes -- and share them!

Not only will the co-owners enjoy more space per person that way, they'll also enjoy the quality of an upper bracket home; live in a (very) nice neighborhood; and possibly even get to enjoy (part of) an especially nice, oversized lot.

Not sure about the parking, though . . .

Saturday, April 24, 2010

"Rehab Novices"

Why Such a Big Discount For
Big Homes Needing Updating?

Want a novel -- but not at all far-fetched -- (additional) explanation for why so many nicer, bigger homes are facing significant discounts in today's market, especially ones that need significant updating?

Keep reading.

Far and away, there are three big reasons why such homes -- let's just say 4 or 5 Bedrooms, 3-4 Baths, with 3,500 to 4,500 finished square feet, in a nice part of town -- are proving tougher to sell. (Note: the price tag for such a home could be anywhere from $600k-$800k (or more) locally, depending on the particulars).

One. The economy. A rough economy shrinks the number of people who can swing a $5,000 monthly mortgage payment, $10k or so in annual property taxes, and the upkeep on a bigger home.
Oh, and since Buyers of such homes typically need a jumbo mortgage, they'll need to put down $50k or $100k instead of a fraction of that amount needed to buy a home under $500k.

Two. Demographics.

The Baby Boom generation now retiring/downsizing is being followed by a smaller generation with fewer, smaller families.

Ergo, demand is less than supply.

Three. Remodeling costs. You can finance a home purchase with a still-cheap 5%-plus mortgage.

Remodeling costs are typically straight out-of-pocket (remember that little Recession we were just in?).

Rehab Novices

That's probably all the explanation needed to explain why bigger, dated homes are taking longer to sell.

But I think there's actually a fourth reason that goes with the other three.

Namely, the resulting "market compression" makes rehab/updating projects especially daunting for the people who would naturally undertake them.

Here's the logic:

Because of the peculiarities of today's market, it's not unusual to see a completely updated, mint condition home with around 2,500 square feet fetch $500k or more, depending on where it's located.

Meanwhile, some 4,000 square foot-plus homes can be had -- especially if they need significant updating -- for $600k to $700k.

What happens when someone who's outgrown their (otherwise perfect) 2,500 square foot home looks at a 4,500 square foot home that needs "everything?"

It looks overwhelming.

That's especially the case if the biggest remodeling project they've tackled previously is a new bathroom.

Ironically, this "feedback loop" results in bigger homes sitting on the market, which results in discounting, which makes them affordable (at least on paper) to more Buyers moving up from smaller homes . . . who find a big project daunting.

No, I can't prove the foregoing -- but my gut (and my Buyer clients) tells me there's something to it . . .

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

The Buy-Versus-Rent Question

Calculating the "Rent Ratio"

Sometimes, the decision whether to buy a home or not seems to require an economics Ph.d.

Are interest rates headed higher? How strong is the economy? Are home prices now recovering, or will there be a "double-dip?"

It's enough to make your head spin -- or hurt.

If the foregoing (unanswerable, by the way) questions seem too daunting, try this one instead:

Can I rent a nicer place for less money than it costs to buy?

In many cities, including Minneapolis, the answer is now "no."

Check out this NYT piece, "In Sour Home Market, Buying Often Now Beats Renting," for the particulars.

Warning: you'll need to divide by 20 to calculate the local "rent ratio" -- the best yardstick for gauging whether buying is a better deal than renting.

If you need help filling in the numerator and denominator . . . . call me! (612-925-7701)

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Twin Cities Market Snapshot -- March, 2010

Today's Buyers: Looking for (Affordable) Cream Puffs

My quick "snapshot" on the Twin Cities housing market as of St. Patrick's Day, 2010?

It continues to be a schizophrenic market, in which the lower end -- defined as under $200k for single family detached -- is selling (too?) briskly, and values are hard to find.

I attribute that to: 1) tax incentives (due to expire April 30) that loom larger for entry-level homes; 2) a preponderance of first-time Buyers unencumbered by existing homes they have to sell; and 3) a pronounced drop in bank foreclosures (down more than 50% locally the last six months).

Meanwhile, upper bracket homes (say, $800k and above) continue to languish, and are being aggressively discounted to move.

Two Contests: Pricing & Beauty

Another phenomenon of this market: Buyers are looking for "cream puff's"; that is, homes in mint -- or at least move-in -- condition that show great . . . and are priced great.

Or as Edina agent Jonathan Spar puts it, would-be Sellers in today's market have to win two contests: a pricing contest, and a beauty contest.

Perhaps that's why I'm seeing more listings that have been sitting, unsold, "re-debut" on the market touting the fact that they are "newly staged" (often with a price reduction, for added "oomph").

That's a tacit acknowledgement that they weren't so beautiful before -- but now they are!

P.S.: sometimes I wonder whether Buyers who fall in love with a home realize that they're buying the home, not the staging!

Thursday, March 11, 2010

Market Activity By Price Point

If a picture is worth a thousand words, take a look at the third slide in the presentation below:


The takeaway? Twin Cities housing sales over the last 12 months are correlated almost 100% with price point.

In other words, the lower the better -- and "upper, upper bracket" is the worst .. .

Wednesday, January 6, 2010

Picking Comp's: Vertical or Horizontal?

What's it Worth? Who Wants to Know?

Pricing well is one of the most important skills a Realtor brings to the table.

In turn, that depends on knowing which "comp's," or comparable sold properties, to choose.

As defined by both Realtors and appraisers, the comp's are the three homes most similar to the "subject property" -- in terms of style, age, square feet, condition, etc. -- that have sold the most recently.

Once you've identified three homes, step 2 is to go through a "compare-and-contrast" analysis juxtaposing each comp with the subject home, adding or subtracting to adjust for the differences (How much? That's another "experience" judgment).

"Vertical" vs. "Horizontal" Selection

By convention, "recently" used to mean the last six months. However, as underwriting standards have tightened in the wake of the housing bust, some banks now insist on three months.

But what if there aren't three good comp's within the last few months? Or even one comp?

That's where it gets interesting.

Appraisers, working for the lender, will typically stick to the shorter timeline and simply look as far afield as necessary to find three similar homes. Call that "horizontal" selection.

By contrast, a good Realtor who knows the area will opt to choose the comp's "vertically," i.e., stay within the immediate neighborhood, and go back as far as necessary to find good sales precedents.

Guess which approach is more accurate?

Inside Information

The latter, because a Realtor who knows the chronology of local neighborhood sales can "connect the dots" going back as far as necessary.

They'll know which homes sold fast, which sold slow, which sale prices were aberrations -- and why.

Armed with that info, they'll have a feel for momentum (or lack thereof) . . . . and can price accordingly.

By contrast, bank appraisers invariably end up comparing geographic apples to oranges.

In their quest to find timely comp's, they'll jump significant -- but invisible -- neighborhood boundaries that render comparisons much more difficult.

Just in Minneapolis and the west suburbs, I can think of numerous, contiguous neighborhoods where you'd never compare a home in one neighborhood with one in another.

Country Club vs. Morningside

To pick just one example, consider Edina's Country Club and Morningside neighborhoods.

Both wonderful neighborhoods, they each have their own characteristic housing stock, supply and demand -- and per square foot selling prices.

Confusing two, disparate areas often leads to homes not appraising when they should -- or Sellers not pricing their homes appropriately.