My blog has moved! Redirecting...

You should be automatically redirected. If not, visit http://rosskaplan.com and update your bookmarks.

Showing posts with label bank bailout. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bank bailout. Show all posts

Friday, November 19, 2010

"Our" Banks, Warren? No, YOUR Banks

Warren Buffett's Freudian Slip

This land is your land
This land is my(?) land
From California to the New York island
From the red wood forest to the Gulf Stream waters
This land was made for you (and me?).

--Lyrics, "This Land is Your Land"; Woody Guthrie (tweaked by Ross Kaplan)

The first time I read "Pretty Good for Government Work," Warren Buffett's defense of the bank bailouts in The New York Times this week, it all seemed perfectly reasonable and logical: the system truly was on the verge of a melt-down in September, 2008, and doing nothing surely would have brought on -- if not a financial apocalypse -- something very, very nasty.

But re-reading it, I couldn't help coming back to a single, offending word: 'our.'

Here's the context:

Just over two years ago, in September 2008, our country faced an economic meltdown. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the pillars that supported our mortgage system, had been forced into conservatorship. Several of our largest commercial banks were teetering. One of Wall Street’s giant investment banks had gone bankrupt, and the remaining three were poised to follow. A.I.G., the world’s most famous insurer, was at death’s door.

--Warren Buffett, "Pretty Good for Government Work"; The New York Times (11/16/2010)

I suppose if I owned tens of millions of shares in Wells Fargo, Wachovia, and Moody's (the credit rating agency); $10 billion in Goldman Sachs bonds that I very much wanted repaid; billions in credit default swap positions, etc. etc. -- I would start to think of the financial system as "our" financial system, too.

But in reality, it's "their" financial system.

They own it, they derive the lion's share of benefits from it, and they -- quite logically -- defend it.

Bailout Red Herring

The second canard buried in Buffett's apologia is the inference that critics of the bailout advocated doing nothing.

Hardly.

Away from the Op-Ed pages of The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times, there has been a deafening chorus -- nay, consensus -- on what government properly should have done -- in fact, should still do now -- in response to the Wall Street-engineered financial melt-down.

Of course, that's after acknowledging that the very best course of action would have been actually trying to prevent it in the first place (vs. enabling it).

In a mythical letter addressed to "Uncle Sucker," Blogger Barry Ritholtz puts it best:

When the crisis struck, you did not seem to understand the role you should play. Instead of stepping up to halt the financialization, to unwind it, you gave away the shop. You failed to extract concessions from firms on the verge of bankruptcy. Your negotiating skills were embarrassing. In the face of meltdown, you panicked.

You could have undone the decades of radical deregulation at that moment. You could have fired the incompetent management, wiped out the shareholders who invested in insolvent companies, gave the creditors and bond holders a major haircut for their foolish lending. Instead, you rewarded them for their gross incompetence.

The solutions you ran with were ad hoc, poorly thought out, improvised. You crossed legal boundaries, putting the Fed in the position of violating its charter and exceeding its mandates. You created a Moral Hazard, the impact of which may not be felt until decades in the future.

--Barry Ritholtz, "Dear Uncle Sucker . . ."; The Big Picture (11/17/2010)

There are no Pulitzers -- yet -- for blog posts, but if there were, I'd nominate "Dear Uncle Sucker."

Read Buffett's piece, then Ritholtz's in its entirety, and decide for yourself.

P.S.: Dear RE/MAX and Coldwell Banker Burnet: looking for an experienced -- albeit opinionated -- Twin Cities Realtor (and blogger)?

If my boss, Mr. Buffett, reads this, I may be available (Buffett is chairman of Berkshire Hathaway, the ultimate parent company of Edina Realty).

Friday, October 15, 2010

No money for foreclosure staff? Hmm, I wonder why . .

"I Gave (and Gave) at the Office"

It's awfully hard to buy the line that banks may not have -- ahem -- strictly complied with the letter of the law in foreclosing upon hundreds of thousands of homes because they were understaffed.

Let's see
. . .

Take the staggering compensation earned by guys like Ken Lewis (ex-CEO of Bank of America) and Jamie Dimon (current CEO of JP Morgan Chase) -- call it, conservatively, $200 million apiece since 2000; divide by what a real worker -- not a "Burger King" flunkie -- makes (call it $40,000 a year); and what do you get?

Money for 5,000 foreclosure positions at each bank.

Think that would have avoided a few problems??

P.S.: what would the government do to an airline that paid its executives millions while neglecting basic plane maintenance and safety?

If there then was a crash -- and we're still dealing with the consequences of a horrific (financial) crash -- you can bet that there'd be hell to pay (not billions in bailout money, with virtually no questions asked).

Sunday, December 20, 2009

Outrage Over Banker Bonuses: Define 'Benefit'

Banker Arrogance, Exhibit #137

Pop quiz: who said the following, in what context?

"We all benefited from the financial system. All of us."

A. President Obama, justifying using trillions in taxpayer money to fortify the nation's too-big-to-fail banks.
B. An anonymous retiree, rationalizing the .25% (as in 4 x .25% = 1%!) annual interest -- before tax! -- that he's now collecting on his savings.
C. Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke, explaining his actions to rescue Wall Street.
D. A latter-day Tiny Tim, expressing gratitude ("God Bless Us, Every One!")
E. One of the millions of U.S. homeowners who lost their home to foreclosure last year -- or are in jeopardy now.
F. Robert Diamond, the President of Barclays Capital, one of Britain's biggest banks, and the recipient, personally, of more than $90 million in bonuses and salary the last 4 years, justifying his paycheck. (Source: 'Executive at Barclays Defends Pay'; The New York Times, 12/19/09)

Answer: F.

And no, Mr. Diamond, it's patently false that "all of us benefited from the financial system" (at the very least, it would seem that some of us "benefited" quite a bit more than others).

P.S.: why does every institution and individual responsible for the financial melt-down have to have a financially tinged surname? Examples: Goldman Sachs, Alan Greenspan, Robert Diamond, etc. Maybe it's easier to identify the culprits that way.

Friday, May 8, 2009

Bank "Stress Test" Results

The "Muddle-Through Strategy"

What we’re really seeing here is a decision on the part of President Obama and his officials to muddle through the financial crisis, hoping that the banks can earn their way back to health . . . maybe we can let the economy fix the banks instead of the other way around.

--Paul Krugman, "Stressing the Positive"; The New York Times (5/8/09)

No, there's been no official pronouncement, but as Krugman details, the administration has clearly adopted what pundits are calling "the muddle-through strategy."

A similar approach worked in the early '90's, after U.S. banks suffered from the collapse of commercial real estate.

Will it this time?

Again, Krugman cuts to the quick.

Whether or not you benefit from Washington's solicitous approach to the big banks "depends on who you are: a banker, or someone trying to make a living in another profession."

Tuesday, March 24, 2009

China: Keep Your Dollars

Is the U.S. Dollar a "Legacy Currency"?

"China Urges New Money Reserve to Replace the Dollar"
--The New York Times (3/24/09)

Legacy: of, relating to, or being a previous or outdated computer system.

Here's a tip: when someone refers to something as a "legacy [blank]," it's not a compliment (or a good omen).

So it's unnerving -- at least to me -- to see Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner refer to the toxic assets at the heart of the most recent bailout plan as "legacy loans" and "legacy securities."

Oh . . and the Chinese, holders of more than $1 trillion in U.S. currency, are increasingly nervous (as well they should be).

Just two weeks after the Russians broached the idea of launching a new, international reserve currency, the Chinese are joining the chorus.

It won't happen overnight; think of switching from U.S. dollars as analogous to supplanting English as the world's predominant language. (A brand, new synthetic currency would then be the equivalent of Esperanto).

But it's a potent signal when this country's biggest creditor essentially utters a "no confidence" vote in our currency.

That's especially so when you consider that China holds so many dollars, it can't really sell them without destabilizing the market, leaving its holdings worth even less.

George Soros on CDS

Everything Clear Now?

Going short on bonds by buying a Credit Default Swap ("CDS") contract carries limited risk but almost unlimited profit potential. By contrast, selling CDS offers limited profits but practically unlimited risks. This asymmetry encourages speculating on the short side, which in turn exerts a downward pressure on the underlying bonds. The negative effect is reinforced by the fact that CDS are tradable and therefore tend to be priced as warrants, which can be sold at anytime, not as options, which would require an actual default to be cashed in.

--George Soros, "One Way to Stop Bear Raids"; The Wall Street
Journal
(3/24/09)

Huh??

There's plenty of commentary out there already on the Treasury's new initiative to buy the big banks' toxic assets. So, I'm not going to add mine.

However, clearly the stock market (or at least Wall Street) loved it: it exploded to the upside yesterday, with the Dow Jones rallying 500 points, or about 7%.

Whatever the merits of Treasury's plan, one thing it is not is clear. Or simple.

Of course, neither are the problems it is attempting to address (Exhibit A is Soros' op-ed piece -- and hundreds more like it. If you're befuddled, Soros, a multi-billionaire and investing legend, is basically saying that flaws in the marketplace permited a "piling-on" phenomenon that led to the fall of financial giants like Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, and AIG).

And still . . . it seems like brain-numbing complexity isn't just symptomatic of the problem in the financial markets, it is the problem. Which means the cure is simplicity.

Put it this way: after witnessing the financial system crash so spectacularly, you'd think the first order of business would be to impose lower speed limits.