My blog has moved! Redirecting...

You should be automatically redirected. If not, visit http://rosskaplan.com and update your bookmarks.

Showing posts with label liquidity trap. Show all posts
Showing posts with label liquidity trap. Show all posts

Thursday, October 28, 2010

Approaching the Zero Bound

"An Attempted Hypodermic
Straight to the Economy’s Heart"

A fascinating, even feverish dialogue is taking place right now -- joined by some of the financial world's most influential thinkers -- concerning what will happen next week, and what economic consequences will flow from that outcome.

The elections next Tuesday?

Try, the Fed's much-signalled intention to initiate another round of quantitative easing (also called "printing money") when it meets next Wednesday.

Here is Bill Gross' take, from his perch at PIMCO, the nation's (world's?) largest investor in bonds:

Quantitative easing is temporarily, but not ultimately, a bondholder’s friend. It raises bond prices to create the illusion of high annual returns, but ultimately it reaches a dead-end where those prices can no longer go up. Having arrived at its destination, the market then offers near 0% returns and a picking of the creditor’s pocket via inflation and negative real interest rates.

--Bill Gross, "Run Turkey, Run"; PIMCO Investment Outlook (Nov., 2010)

So why do it?

Because the Fed, caught in a liquidity trap, is out of other options.

Gross again:

Ben Bernanke can’t raise or lower taxes, he can’t direct a fiscal thrust of infrastructure spending, he can’t change our educational system, he can’t force the Chinese to revalue their currency – it (more quantitative easing) is all he can do.

--Bill Gross

Will "it" work?

Gross, whose credentials are as good as anyone's, thinks the jury's out.

Monday, July 5, 2010

"Bloodletting" Economists

Economic Theory, Then & Now

The U.S. is now 234 years old, and yet over half the nation’s money supply was created since Helicopter Ben took over the flight controls four years ago.

--David Rosenberg; Chief Economist, Gluskin Sheff

It's hardly a saving grace for today's financial mess, but it HAS been gratifying to see an entire generation of muckety-muck economists abruptly lose their hubris regarding their colleagues of yore.

As epitomized by the last two Fed Chairmen, Alan Greenspan and Ben Bernanke, the prevailing mindset amongst contemporary economists has been that their Depression-era peers were little more advanced than medieval doctors, who went in for bloodletting and other harmful quackery.

The reason for that belief?

Those in charge during the Great Depression ignorantly presided over a collapse in the money supply, with a consequently ruinous effect on credit availability, debt repayment, and wages and prices generally (indeed, the Depression was characterized by a devastating deflation).

Fighting the Last War?

Fast forward to today.

"Helicopter Ben" Bernanke and the U.S. Treasury have now injected -- depending on how you count -- somewhere on the order of $10 trillion in liquidity into the U.S. economy.

And that's just since 2008.

Zero percent interest rates. TARP. Son of TARP. Federal guaranties. Bailouts. Direct equity infusions. Subsidized mortgage rates. Quantitative easing. And on and on.

The result?

No Great Depression II, but certainly not a robust recovery. And at the cost of trillions in potentially crippling, new U.S. debt.

In fact, by printing so much money, Mr. Bernanke has ushered in what economists call a "liquidity trap": monetary policy has eased so much -- in fact, to 0% -- that further easing has no effect.
In fact, it's impossible (cue, quantitative easing).

Back to the ???

So, where do we go from here?

Not necessarily 'back to the '30's.

Personally, I'd settle for the '50's.

Saturday, October 31, 2009

"The Biggest Loser"

Revisionist History

As historians know full well, Presidential reputations sometimes take decades to settle out, experiencing ups and downs in the meantime.

For example, Harry Truman left office in 1953 quite unpopular.

Over time, though, his stock gradually rose as society came to appreciate -- after the fact -- his straight-talking populism, common sense, and decency.

It also helped that, unlike contemporaries, later generations were less inclined to see him in FDR's (enormous) shadow.

Ironically, Truman's successor, Dwight D. Eisenhower, was another politician who left office under appreciated.

Viewed through the prism of the tumultuous '60's and turbulent '70's, the relatively placid '50's that Eisenhower presided over could easily inspire nostalgia a generation later. The nation's top general in World War II, his prescient valedictory warning about the "military-industrial complex" has also endeared him to posterity.

Finally, later generations, who only caught glimpses of JFK's charisma on movie reels, were more inclined to focus on JFK's substance and record (promising but incomplete) rather than his style (dazzling).

Today's Crop of Leaders

So, roughly two years into what appears to be shaping up as The Great Recession, how do today's leaders and recent-leaders fare?

Using a scale of minus-100 (-100) to plus-100 (+100), here's my take on the shifts to date:

Paul Volcker. Then: 50; Now: 100. Net gain: +50. Steered the country through the last comparable mess in the early '80's. Never worked for Goldman Sachs -- or aspired to. None of this would have happened on his watch. Tall Paul, indeed.

Alan Greenspan: Then: 90; Now: -75. Net loss: -165 (sets "the Biggest Loser" bar for a long time). "The maestro" now "the charlatan." Every one of his major tenets and policies have now been discredited if not repudiated, i.e., : 1) markets are self-regulating; 2) the Fed's job is to mitigate the damage from bubbles, not identify and prevent them; 3) financial actors pursue self-preservation above all other goals (wrong! they chase short-term profits and maximum compensation); and 4) excessively accommodative monetary policies don't risk liquidity traps (wrong! they do -- and we're clearly in one now).

Bill Clinton: Then: 40. Now: 10. Net loss: -30. The "Party Hearty" President from Arkansas (by way of Yale and Oxford). If the 1990's were the 1920's redux, that makes Clinton this era's Coolidge -- a feel good, go-with-the-flow leader whose lieutenants (Rubin, Summers, et al) did everything they could to keep the party going.

Ronald Reagan: Then: 60. Now: 40. Net loss: -20. Yeah, he gets splattered by this, too. Conservatives' darling, he pushed the pendulum rightward at a time when there was a strong case for it (sorry, liberals, but the Great Society overshot, and Carter never measured up). Unfortunately, the pendulum . . . kept going.

On the other hand, Reagan's resolve and optimism were a welcome tonic after Carter's malaise. He also gets much credit for the demise of the Soviet Union ("a good thing," as Martha Stewart would say).

Bonus question: if Reagan had been President 20 years later, would he have recognized the financial excesses, and shifted course? (He did finally fire Don Regan, formerly head of Merrill Lynch, but mostly because he was a jerk, not over policy disagreements).

Herbert Hoover: Then: -90. Now: -40. Net gain: +50. OK, he screwed it up. But it was harder to get right than we thought. At least his Treasury Secretary did what he thought was best for the country, not his own pocket or Goldman Sachs'.

FDR: Then: +70. Now: +90. Net gain: +20. Another beneficiary of "it was harder to get right than we thought." They were lucky to have him (and where's ours??)

George W. Bush: Who?