My blog has moved! Redirecting...

You should be automatically redirected. If not, visit http://rosskaplan.com and update your bookmarks.

Showing posts with label deflation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label deflation. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 20, 2010

A Tale of Two . . . Chairs

"Hedonics," Defined

After almost 13 years, I finally popped for a new (home) office chair yesterday.

The chair I retired -- actually, handed down to son #2 -- was an ergonomically correct, (then) state-of-the-art job purchased from a Relax the Back store in Manhattan for almost $800 in early 1998.

Truth be told, it was an engagement gift from my then-fiance (not very romantic, unless you consider functionality romantic -- which I do).

While still serviceable, the gas lift had worn out, leaving me literally deflated and my rear end only about a foot off the ground.

Chair #2

I replaced it with a Chinese knock-off of the trendy Herman Miller Aeron chair pictured above.

Office Max had it discounted from the usual $175 to only $99.

Based on my "challenges" assembling various Ikea products, I braced for a long evening parsing instructions, puzzling over seemingly missing and mismatched parts, etc.

Instead, I found the instructions to be clear and concise, and assembled everything in 20 minutes, tops.

Chair Buyers vs. Chair Makers

Using only these two chairs as a microcosm, what can you say about how the economy has changed the last 13 years?

A couple observations come to mind:

--Cheap, overseas manufacturing is a mixed blessing.

As consumers, we definitely benefit from cheaper, imported goods.

As taxpayers and U.S. citizens, though, the loss of U.S. jobs undermines our well-being -- especially if your job used to be manufacturing office chairs.

Call it "the Wal-Mart effect" in a nutshell.

--Prices of many goods, especially manufactured ones, have experienced marked price deflation.

In fact, the $800-to-$99 price drop understates the deflationary effect.

That's because $1 in 1998 is worth about half that in 2010.

--Advances in product quality and features make apples-to-apples price comparisons difficult.

Not only is my Office Max chair dramatically cheaper than my old one, it has features the other one lacked: lumbar support adjustments, tension settings, etc.

How do you track price changes when products actually become better over time?

This challenge has given rise to the pseudo-science of "hedonics."

Hedonics Example

To take another example, consider a circa 2010 car, selling for $25,000, that has anti-lock brakes, power steering, and front and side air bags as standard equipment.

Now compare it to its 1995 counterpart -- lacking those features -- that sold for $15,000.

The $64,000 question: did car prices go up the last 15 years, and if so, how much?

At least nominally, they did, because $25,000 is more than $15,000.

On the other hand, the 2010 car buyer got more for their (less valuable) $25,000.

The answers to the foregoing are far from clear, and the stuff of what economists spend their time arguing about (no doubt sitting in their $99 Chinese knock-off chairs).

Tuesday, July 20, 2010

Jeremy Grantham on "the 'Flation Issue"

As Flummoxed as Everyone Else

What we are seeing now is a tussle between the 50% sustained speculation branch and the branch where two or three things go wrong and crack confidence. This struggle is an unusual one, and has created market effects I have never seen before, and you have not either.

--Jeremy Grantham, GMO Q2 2010 Newsletter

Somewhere [in the last 30 years], without any formal announcement of the change, the “client” in a trade mutated into a “counterparty” who could be exploited.

--Jeremy Grantham, GMO Q2 2010 Newsletter

Today is "Jeremy Grantham day" on the financial blogosphere.

That's because the influential investor just released his most recent quarterly newsletter.

For once, I didn't glean anything new or groundbreaking; the main highlight making the rounds is that Grantham has officially come down on the "deflation" side of the 'flation issue, at least in the short run.

The other sign that Grantham is flummoxed by today's uncharted financial waters: his three "weighted probability" scenarios, in which the chance of a big "up" move is put as just about the same as a big "down" move.

He might as well have just shrugged his shoulders.

Monday, July 5, 2010

"Bloodletting" Economists

Economic Theory, Then & Now

The U.S. is now 234 years old, and yet over half the nation’s money supply was created since Helicopter Ben took over the flight controls four years ago.

--David Rosenberg; Chief Economist, Gluskin Sheff

It's hardly a saving grace for today's financial mess, but it HAS been gratifying to see an entire generation of muckety-muck economists abruptly lose their hubris regarding their colleagues of yore.

As epitomized by the last two Fed Chairmen, Alan Greenspan and Ben Bernanke, the prevailing mindset amongst contemporary economists has been that their Depression-era peers were little more advanced than medieval doctors, who went in for bloodletting and other harmful quackery.

The reason for that belief?

Those in charge during the Great Depression ignorantly presided over a collapse in the money supply, with a consequently ruinous effect on credit availability, debt repayment, and wages and prices generally (indeed, the Depression was characterized by a devastating deflation).

Fighting the Last War?

Fast forward to today.

"Helicopter Ben" Bernanke and the U.S. Treasury have now injected -- depending on how you count -- somewhere on the order of $10 trillion in liquidity into the U.S. economy.

And that's just since 2008.

Zero percent interest rates. TARP. Son of TARP. Federal guaranties. Bailouts. Direct equity infusions. Subsidized mortgage rates. Quantitative easing. And on and on.

The result?

No Great Depression II, but certainly not a robust recovery. And at the cost of trillions in potentially crippling, new U.S. debt.

In fact, by printing so much money, Mr. Bernanke has ushered in what economists call a "liquidity trap": monetary policy has eased so much -- in fact, to 0% -- that further easing has no effect.
In fact, it's impossible (cue, quantitative easing).

Back to the ???

So, where do we go from here?

Not necessarily 'back to the '30's.

Personally, I'd settle for the '50's.

Tuesday, December 16, 2008

Balky Buyers, Borrowers

Combating a Deflationary Mindset

One of the unintended consequences of falling prices -- for new homes, existing homes, mortgage rates, etc. -- is that would-be Buyers get out of the way, and wait for even bigger drops. There's some anecdotal evidence that that's the psychology behind many Buyers' reluctance to buy or even refinance at the moment. (Of course, a weak economy and rising unemployment have their own chilling effect.)

To pick just one example in the housing market, 30 year mortgage rates are now at 5%, the lowest they've been in more than 50 years, and significantly below the rates that prevailed during the market peak in 2006. However, many Buyers' reaction is to wait and see if rates improve even more.

On a national scale, when this "wait for better prices tomorrow" mindset takes hold, it's called deflation, and quickly becomes self-reinforcing. The need to combat this is one of the organizing principles underlying recent Fed and Treasury action(s).

At least in the housing market, there are steps you can take to mitigate the "risk" of missing out on even better prices tomorrow. For a nominal fee, many mortgage lenders offer a "re-lock" option that lets borrowers switch to a lower rate while their application is pending.