My blog has moved! Redirecting...

You should be automatically redirected. If not, visit http://rosskaplan.com and update your bookmarks.

Showing posts with label Purchase Agreement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Purchase Agreement. Show all posts

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Multiple Offers . . . in Progress

"Hmm, I Wonder Where That Lockbox Key Went??"

An interesting little contest is shaping up over a certain Twin Cities foreclosure that came on the market yesterday for 50% of its tax assessed value.

I am withholding the address because I have a client interested in buying it, but here's the background:

A saved search on my computer popped up the home 90 minutes after it hit the market yesterday morning.

Because the agent remarks indicated the home was "As is," and the price was tantalizingly low, I called the listing agent to make sure it didn't need hundreds of thousands of dollars in repairs.

"Negative," he said.

"But, it's already sold," he continued.

"The bank already signed an offer that came in the first 45 minutes it was on the market."

The Plot Thickens

Yowza.

With all the details involved in getting a Purchase Agreement executed, it's almost inevitable that there'll be at least one loose end -- especially if there's a bank involved, as is the case here -- that will give one party or the other an out.

And with instant, multiple offers, that's exactly what the bank wanted.

So late last night, I received an email from the listing agent indicating that the first, supposedly accepted offer wasn't in fact completely executed, and that all interested parties were invited to join the bidding.

Sand in the Gears

Once whoever took the keys and lockbox cover returns them, that is.

It turns out that the (vacant) home wasn't available to be shown almost all of yesterday because the lockbox keys (and cover) had been removed.

The agent's email publicly asks whoever took them to return them -- their identity isn't really much of mystery to the listing agent, who knows exactly who got in yesterday and who didn't (or soon will).

The listing agent's email continues that the bidding process for the property will be delayed until the key is returned, and that if it isn't promptly returned, the locks will be changed to accommodate agents whose showings were thwarted yesterday.

Nice to see a listing agent handling it this way: level playing field, open and transparent communication to all interested parties, etc.

Real Estate "Whodunit"

Ditching the lockbox key is actually pretty rare (If I had any doubts about the screaming deal this home represents -- I don't now).

It's also more likely to backfire on the agent pulling it; clearly, it's already seriously annoyed the listing agent, which is never a good thing.

It's also eminently traceable, given how well-documented showing requests are today (100% computer-driven).

By contrast, in my first week of law school school in 1987, when a certain dusty treatise that everyone needed for a research project disappeared . . . it wasn't so easy to trace.

Want to find out what happens to "the home with the missing keys" next?

Stay tuned . . . .

Friday, October 8, 2010

Pre-Approval Letters & Written Statements

What Are They Really Worth?

Put it this way: the picture of toilet paper should give you a hint.

First, some background.

In Minnesota, the first things that typically lead off any offer to purchase residential real estate are the Buyer's earnest money check, and a pre-approval letter from a lender (unless the Buyer is paying cash).

The standard pre-approval letter recites that the lender has initially screened the Buyer's finances and credit scores, and, based on that quick review, says that the Buyer can afford the home.

In practice, a pre-approval letter almost always means . . . nothing.

Most lenders will issue them in less than 10 minutes on the phone with a prospective borrower, after collecting the most basic information.

Meanwhile, their express language explicitly states that nothing in the pre-approval letter obligates the lender issuing it to actually fund the loan.

The Written Statement

Which is where the Written Statement supposedly comes in (think of it as "the Final Approval" Letter).

Once the Buyer and Seller reach agreement on terms, the Purchase Agreement typically includes a Financing Addendum that calls for the Buyer to deliver a Written Statement within 2-3 weeks.

The standard Written Statement recites that an appraisal satisfactory to the lender has been completed; presumes that the lender has finished vetting the Buyer's W-2's, recent tax returns, and any other Buyer financial "bona fides"; and lists any outstanding conditions remaining -- usually pro forma ones, like the Buyer not blowing up their credit or losing their job.

Once the Buyer delivers the Written Statement to the Seller, the Buyer's loan is supposed to be finally underwritten -- and the Buyer's earnest money becomes non-refundable.

O-for-2

Except that in practice, that's not how it works today.

Now, skittish lenders can and do reserve the right to revisit the loan at any time up until closing.

They may request additional Comp's to substantiate the value of the collateral (the home being purchased); ask the Buyer for (still) more financial documentation; or tweak (tighten) their underwriting standards.

Or all of the above.

The result?

What was supposed to be a finally underwritten loan suddenly . . . isn't.

All of the foregoing means two things:

One. Buyers and Sellers today, especially when upper bracket properties are involved, should consider drafting custom language to address the Buyer's financial qualifications, and defining when their earnest money becomes non-refundable; and

Two. Sellers shouldn't load up the moving van until they know, for sure, that the Buyer's financing is good.

Monday, August 30, 2010

Housing Market "Do Si Do"

"Pick Your (Housing) Partner"

Swing your partner ‘round and ‘round,
And turn your corner upside down.
And turn your corner like swingin’ on a gate,
And meet your partner for
a grand chain eight,
And hurry up boys and don’t be late.

--Square dancing lyrics

What does the upcoming Fall housing market have to do with square dancing?

It's when Buyers and Sellers "pick their partners," before colder weather and the holidays slow things down. (Ditto for landlords and renters).

So here's a rare (but safe) prediction from yours truly:

The Twin Cities housing market is going to accelerate noticeably after Labor Day.

Assuming that most people want to close by Thanksgiving, and taking into account that the average interval between signing a Purchase agreement and closing is six weeks, Buyers and Sellers will want to consummate a deal by early October.

P.S.: as part of that acceleration, look for a spike in new listings and price reductions after Labor Day.

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

"Negotiating Least"

"Brittle" vs. "Supple" Deals

He who negotiates least, negotiates best.

--saying

OK, so that's not how it goes (the original version substituted "government" and "governing").

But it's still accurate.

There are 3 reasons why that's so, at least that I can think of.

One. While some people actually like to negotiate -- Realtors often do, for one -- for most people, negotiating is stressful.

As the number of rounds of negotiating climbs, stress rises, conflict increases --and the chance of a good outcome slide.

Two. Related to that, while the two sides' stress is rising, their negotiating positions often harden.

That's in contrast to brief(er) negotiations, when positions are more fluid and ground is easier to close.

Three. Real estate deals these days involve more rounds.

First, there's getting to terms regarding the main Purchase Agreement.

Then, there's the Inspection Contingency.

Then, there's the Financing Contingency, which itself is much more protracted these days -- mainly because of stricter appraisal rules.

When the Buyer and Seller have exhausted each other and it's not even the second inning yet . . . the chances of getting a consummated deal ("a complete game," to continue the metaphor) aren't great.

Tuesday, July 20, 2010

Fewer Purchase Agreements, More Leases

Mastering the Rental Market

Want to know which way the (real estate) wind is blowing?

Here's what's on the agenda for this year's Minnesota Association of Realtors forms course:

New this year are lease contracts, exclusive representation for consumers looking to rent, and lease listing forms.

Detect a theme?

In a market with more rental activity and fewer Buyers . . . more Realtors are getting up to speed helping clients find rentals (I seem to recall something about lemons and lemonade . . )

Sunday, May 2, 2010

Official Time of "Birth": 10:17 p.m. on 4/30/2010

Under the Tax Credit Deadline (Just!)

Communities large and small traditionally attach a lot of fanfare to the first birth of the new year.

So, the proud parents of little Susie or Tommy, who arrived at 12:03 a.m. on New Year's Day, typically rate a mention in the paper or news (and often a free year's supply of diapers from an obliging sponsor!).

Is it too late for Realtors to do that?

My client and I (and his Seller and Realtor) were no doubt beat by at least a couple other deals that cut it closer to the wire.

However, the official "Final Acceptance" on my client's Minnetonka townhome purchase -- marking when all the necessary signatures have been obtained, and the executed documents delivered to the Buyer's agent (me) -- was officially 10:17 p.m on Friday night.

Just in case the IRS comes calling, I subsequently faxed the executed Purchase Agreement to my client, generated a time stamp, and scanned and emailed that to him as well.

Friday, May 15, 2009

"Highest & Best," Explained

Multiple Offer "Rules of Engagement":
Highest (Offer) & Best (Terms)

Careful readers of MLS listings these days will notice more references to the phrase "highest and best" -- as in "highest and best offers due by noon, Tuesday."

What exactly is the listing agent talking about? Two things.

First, multiple offers have been received for the property in question (duh!).

Yes, these are increasingly common at the lower end of the market, particularly with bank-owned foreclosures priced, shall we say, "conservatively."

Once it's apparent that there are going to be numerous offers, a standard tack is to inform both prospective Buyers who've already submitted offers, as well as those who are on the verge of doing so. A deadline 24 or 48 hours away is announced, and everyone gets a chance to (re)bid.

Two. "Highest and Best" also means, "one round, with no chance to raise."

I've had more than one client, who, upon learning that their offer in a "multiples" situation fell short, insist on submitting a higher offer.

Unh-unh -- that's not how "highest and best" works (assuming, of course, the Seller is playing by the rules).

In fact, that's the whole logic behind "highest and best."

Instead of going multiple rounds with multiple Buyers, the Seller is basically saying, "cut to the chase and get to your highest offer -- with the best terms (contingencies, closing date, etc.) -- now."

Buyers in this situation not only have to decide what the property is worth to them -- they also have to guess what it's worth to the competition!

Friday, February 27, 2009

Today's Buyer: A Composite

What Do Today's Home Buyers Look Like?

Contrary to popular opinion, home buyers are not an endangered (or extinct) species. Two of my clients just purchased homes, and three more are actively looking.

So what generalizations can you make about them?

They have many (if not all) of the following four attributes:

One. First-time Buyers.

Yes, it's a lot easier to buy if you don't need to sell first.

If you currently own a home and want to buy another, you must either: 1) qualify to own two homes at once, which means an interval of "doubled-up" mortgage payments, utility bills (even if one set is lower because you're not living there), etc.; or 2) make a contingent offer.

That means your offer is contingent on getting a signed Purchase Agreement on your current home, typically within 90 days.

While more Sellers are ok with that in today's market, others want the certainty of a done deal, even if it means accepting a lower price.

Of course, another reason buying is easier for first-timer's is all the incentives being thrown at them.

I'll leave a comprehensive list of programs and incentives for another post, but suffice to say, if you're a first-time buyer and can't find a carrot (or several) for buying right now . . . you're not looking very hard.

Two. Long-term orientation.

I think it's safe to say that the people not buying now are focused on the (downward) direction of home prices.

Which is perfectly understandable.

No one wants to catch a falling knife, and right now the velocity of that knife is record-setting, particularly in places like Las Vegas, Phoenix, and parts of California.

By contrast, many of today's Buyers don't really care what prices will be next year or even three years from now because they're not contemplating selling then.

Rather, they see themselves as locking in their long-term housing costs at today's historically low rates. No matter what housing prices or interest rates do from here, they know that their monthly living costs will be a fixed $1,200, or $2,000 (or whatever).

Three. Financially conservative (or related to someone who is).

It's certainly possible to buy today with as little as 3% or 4% down, particularly for Buyers going through FHA. However, putting more down gives you more options: you can "go conventional" (get a regular bank-issued mortgage); it may qualify you for a lower interest rate (surprise, surprise); and it will help you avoid the various add-on fees becoming popular with lenders.

Also unsurprisingly, Buyers coming in with a heftier downpayment are more popular with Sellers, who don't have to "sweat" the Buyer's financing contingency (the vast majority of Purchase Agreements give the Buyer a prescribed amount of time to secure their mortgage).

When credit was readily flowing, Sellers really didn't care where the Buyer's money was coming from; they knew it would be there at closing. So financially strong Buyers couldn't really get much of a discount.

Today, Sellers can't take anything for granted.

As a result, financially strong Buyers -- making low-risk offers with big downpayments -- can often command a discount from nervous Sellers.

Of course, putting more down means re-paying less.

That same financial conservatism carries over into Buyers' borrowing decisions.

Forget about exotic, adjustable rate loans; they just want plain vanilla, fixed, at the lowest rate they can get.

Four. Custom wants and needs.

I just sold a 4,000 square foot duplex with prehistoric wiring (amongst many other problems) to couple moving to the Twin Cities from Chicago.

Big obstacles, right? Perhaps for many Buyers.

However, one of the clients is a potter who wants to put in a kiln. As a result, they wanted a property where they could install a high-end, 200 amp-plus electric service. Buying a "blank slate" property -- with a discount to match -- suited their needs much better than retrofitting something closer to "move-in ready" condition.

Obviously, not every client needs an in-home kiln (for some odd reason, though, I've now had three clients who have!)

However, plenty of Buyers are looking for homes that they can put their own "stamp" on, whether it means creating a new Kitchen, opening up walls to create a more open floor plan, or simply updating to their taste.

For the first time in a long while, such homes are in plentiful supply, at prices that are likely to prove good, long-term values.

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Foreclosure Headache #7 (and #9, #17, #22, etc.)

Lack of Standardized Contracts
Creates Foreclosure Can of Worms


From a realtor's perspective, representing a Buyer trying to purchase a foreclosure can present an endless can of worms.

For starters, there's the issue of the house's condition. What is it?

Unlike a typical owner-occupied home, there are no disclosures, and the Buyer usually must agree to purchase "as-is." Since no one's home, literally, anything can -- and does -- go wrong. Because foreclosed homes in Minnesota are frequently winterized, one of the first issues to negotiate is how -- and sometimes even if -- the prospective Buyer can test the plumbing, heating, and other major mechanical systems.

A second hurdle is response time. Unlike a typical deal, where a sale negotiation can be consummated in 24-48 hours, with many banks the equivalent timetable is weeks (I've even heard of months, in a few cases).

However, undoubtedly the biggest headache associated with foreclosures is, shall we say, the "variety" of bank-required contracts (suffice to say, there are as many bank-required legal forms circulating as there are bank-owned properties). That lack of standardization not only creates a great deal of uncertainty, but can be time-consuming, and can present novel traps and pitfalls for Buyers (and their realtors) each transaction.

Not Just "Boilerplate"

One of the biggest advances in residential real estate the last few decades, at least in Minnesota, is the adoption of standardized purchase agreements and addenda. While the 20-odd page, single-spaced contract you signed when you purchased your home last year may have said "Edina Realty," "Coldwell Banker Burnet," or "ReMAX," the underlying document is the same in virtually every deal.

As Martha Stewart might say, "that's a good thing."

Unbeknownst to most consumers (and unfortunately, not a few realtors), the standard real estate contract is a dynamic, constantly evolving document.

In fact, each year, the purchase forms undergo a series of tweaks and adjustments to address new market conditions (like the prevalence of short sales now); conform with any new state or federal law; and to refine earlier language that has proved problematic.

That combination of standardization and constant updating greatly streamlines the deal process, by creating conventions for handling the complications and ambiguities that can be part of any transaction.

To pick just one example, consider the Financing Addendum.

The standard Minnesota form balances the Buyer's need for time to firm up their financing with the Seller's need for certainty. The compromise is to set a specific date by which the Buyer's lender is to provide a "Written Statement" to the Seller indicating that the Buyer has secured their financing.

What happens if the Buyer's lender doesn't do that? The Addendum explicitly addresses what happens to the Buyer's earnest money, the effect on the transaction, each party's relative rights, etc.

Custom Contracts

Now throw all that out and start over with the bank's required forms.

How much time is the Buyer allowed to line up their financing? How are they to communicate lender approval? What happens if they can't get it? Under what circumstances does the Seller get to keep the Buyer's earnest money -- and when do they have to give it back?

As they say, "read the fine print." And if the fine print happens to be ambiguous . . . prepare for some friction and (more) delay, at the very least. (As a general proposition, you can assume that banks are inserting/deleting language to increase their rights and limit their liabilities relative to Buyers.)

Similar issues can arise regarding the Inspection timing and the Buyer's ability to back out; the scope of Seller disclosures (usually, just disclaimers); and responsibility for any third-party claims on the property (delinquent taxes, contractor liens, etc.).

After navigating all these issues, and investing a few months of their time, Buyers (and their realtors) are as likely as not to discover that the Buyer's offer has been knocked out by another, higher one.

For all this aggravation, you'd think realtors would get a bonus, right? No way.

Not only is the typical foreclosure steeply discounted from the average market price (about $180,000 now), but the "payout" (the commission offered to the Buyer's realtor) is heavily discounted, too.